“many Israelis see the demise of the country as not just possible, but probable. The State of Israel has been established, not its permanence”

Author Date

…many Israelis see the demise of the country as not just possible, but probable. The State of Israel has been established, not its permanence. The most common phrase in Israeli political discourse is some variation of “If X happens (or doesn’t), the state will not survive!” Those who assume that Israel will always exist as a Zionist project should consider how quickly the Soviet, Pahlavi Iranian, apartheid South African, Baathist Iraqi and Yugoslavian states unraveled, and how little warning even sharp-eyed observers had that such transformations were imminent.

In all these cases, presumptions about what was “impossible” helped protect brittle institutions by limiting political imagination. And when objective realities began to diverge dramatically from official common sense, immense pressures accumulated.

Ian S. Lustick, “The Two-State Illusion”, The New York Times (15 September 2013), SR6.

Related posts:

  1. “All Zionists agree also that an undivided Jerusalem must remain Israel’s capital”
  2. Zionism was a matter that Orthodox rabbis sermonized in the 1920s and 1930s
  3. “Spending a year in Israel has been a constructive rite of passage for thousands of Jewish kids for decades”
  4. “Students who attend college after a year in Israel have a sophisticated, multidimensional view of Israel”