Halakhah, Haredim/Haredi-ism, Modern Orthodoxy “For Rabbi Gordimer, all poskim share the same ‘process’. Not only is this historically incorrect, it isn’t even ‘doctrine'” Author Drew Kaplan Date 17 February 2016 Rabbi Gordimer claims that there is no such thing as Modern Orthodox pesak, and...
Modern Orthodoxy, Open Orthodoxy “…if there wasn’t an Open Orthodoxy to kick around, YU and Modern Orthodoxy would once again be the focus” Author Drew Kaplan Date 16 February 2016 This obsession with the Open Orthodox reminds me of how in earlier centuries Christian...
Modern Orthodoxy, Open Orthodoxy “…Gordimer seems not only unwilling to negotiate that balance…” Author Drew Kaplan Date 14 February 2016 …object of Gordimer’s displeasure is the “Joy of Text” podcast, which discusses matters of...
Modern Orthodoxy, Open Orthodoxy, Orthodoxy “Gordimer’s approach would ultimately consign Modern Orthodoxy to the ash heaps of Jewish history for its irrelevance. It’s also anti-historic” Author Drew Kaplan Date 11 February 2016 For those of us on the fence about these issues, Gordimer’s dialectic is untenable,...
Modern Orthodoxy, Open Orthodoxy “…a wider battle taking place between the Modern Orthodox establishment, led nominally by the RCA, and a vocal left-wing minority known as Open Orthodoxy” Author Drew Kaplan Date 10 February 2016 …last week’s uproar offers another occasion, far from the first in recent years, to...
Modern Orthodoxy, Open Orthodoxy “Gordimer’s tactics do achieve one purpose; they squelch free and open debate” Author Drew Kaplan Date 9 February 2016 Gordimer’s tactics do achieve one purpose; they squelch free and open debate. It’s always...
Open Orthodoxy ” The overall impression from Gordimer’s oeuvre is not that he has a critique of Open Orthodoxy based on particular issues, but based on their character…” Author Drew Kaplan Date 2 February 2016 Whatever you want to say about Open Orthodoxy, the attacks on it, particularly from...
Modern Orthodoxy, Orthodoxy “Orthodox Judaism today is not struggling against the allure of a more Protestant Americanized ethos” Author Drew Kaplan Date 2 February 2016 Orthodox Judaism today is not struggling against the allure of a more Protestant Americanized...
Modern Orthodoxy “Modern Orthodoxy…will have to invest in initiatives that engage the social, cultural, and political issues of the day…” Author Drew Kaplan Date 31 January 2016 As for the broader challenges confronting Modern Orthodoxy, its religious and lay leadership, if...
Modern Orthodoxy, Open Orthodoxy, Orthodoxy “Gordimer’s refusal/failure to propose a new model of Modern Orthodoxy…bespeaks a failure in his thinking…” Author Drew Kaplan Date 31 January 2016 Orthodox Jewry of our days needs new constructs. Tradition, once again needs to be...